asked by thecircuitboards: "With the two main Superhoodie theories (loop and multi-verse), I honestly can't decide which to believe. They each have evidence to support them. All I can say is one part of some people's theories that I do not believe whatsoever. That, in my opinion, has no actual evidence to it. The theory that F!Simon was not in love with Alisha/came from a timeline where they were not together.

The way he looked at her (ex: during *the* scene where she took her shirt off), the way he held her (ex: those touches on the cheek), he made everything about her (ex: she's the reason he went back or at least the main reason), he knows her body completely (ex: *ahem* no example needed for this, right?), he knows her ways (ex: those small smirks he would give after she snapped) and he died for her.

What would he possibly gain from "risking [his] life traveling through the dimensions of time" and manipulating someone who he wasn't close to? If F!Simon was the manipulating character that theory makes he out to be, it would contradict each other in a way. A manipulating character is selfish, obviously. So the fact that with this theory he wouldn't even see the benefits of his manipulation goes against why manipulative people manipulate...so that they specifically can reap the rewards (not the other versions of themselves). If anything, I feel that he told Alisha because he couldn't help himself (which seems to be implied from Superhoodie's twitter) or that he was simply reminding her (like allthemisfits said earlier).

That above was more for the multi-verse theory though because it's impossible to believe in the time loop theory and the lying F!Simon theory. Why? Um...we're watching them fall in love right now then if you believe the time loop. Hehe.

I just had to get that out.

P.S.: Awesome, epic, fantastic, awepictastic chat yesterday! I will totally be at the next one too! :DD"

Wait are you in my head?!? cause I feel you are in my head. Your theory, everything you said is EXACTLY my thoughts and reasoning behind the theories (even the scene examples that you gave). His face in the screencap below is my #1 reason as to why I can’t buy the ‘he was never in love with her’ theory. JUST LOOK AT THE WAY HE IS LOOKING AT HER! YOU CANNOT FAKE THAT FOR YOUR LIFE.

I am glad you had fun because so did Maryam and I! Can’t wait for the rewatch of 204 :D

-Colie